Socrates (469–399 BCE) left no writings of his own, yet few figures have had a larger presence in the history of reading and argument. We meet him in other people’s works: questioning, defending himself, irritating an interlocutor or discussing how a person should live. A first encounter therefore involves two subjects at once—the Athenian philosopher and the writers who made him a literary character.
An Athenian life and its difficult sources
Socrates lived in fifth-century Athens, through the Peloponnesian War and severe political upheaval. In 399 BCE, he was tried on charges involving impiety and the corruption of the young, convicted and executed. The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy’s account places the trial within the city’s religious and political circumstances.
Beyond that outline, reconstructing his life is difficult. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy’s entry explains the “Socratic problem”: separating the historical person from the differing representations of him. Plato, Xenophon and Aristophanes are major sources, but their purposes and literary forms are different. A comic play, a defence of someone’s character and a philosophical dialogue do not supply interchangeable kinds of evidence.
This is a reason to identify the author when discussing a passage. “Plato’s Socrates argues…” is often more accurate than presenting a line as a securely recorded utterance by the historical man. It also makes the reading more interesting, because the scene and the writer’s choices become part of the question.
Apology: a defence, not an expression of regret
Plato’s Apology presents Socrates speaking in his own defence. The title uses “apology” in the sense of a defence of a position or conduct. Readers expecting a confession of error will instead encounter an explanation of why Socrates considers his activity valuable and why he resists demands to abandon it.
The speech distinguishes older prejudices against him from the immediate accusations at his trial. It also recounts his questioning of people reputed to possess wisdom. The point is not a celebration of knowing nothing at all: Socrates tests whether confidence is supported by an account that survives examination.
Read the changes in audience and circumstance carefully. The defence before the verdict, the discussion of a penalty and the final address do different things. A memorable sentence taken from one stage can lose force when detached from the decision being faced. The complete text makes that structure visible.
Euthyphro: testing a definition
In Euthyphro, Socrates encounters a man confident about the meaning of piety. The conversation moves from particular examples towards a demand for an explanation of what makes all pious actions pious. Offering a case and explaining the principle that identifies such cases are different tasks.
The dialogue’s best-known problem concerns the relationship between divine approval and piety. Is something pious because the gods love it, or do they love it because it is pious? The distinction asks whether approval creates the relevant quality or responds to a quality already present. Plato develops it through questions and replies rather than placing a finished theory before the reader.
A useful way to read the dialogue is to write down each proposed definition before moving to the objection. Notice exactly why a proposal is changed. That small discipline prevents the exchange from becoming a blur of clever questions and makes disagreement with Socrates possible on specific grounds.
Crito: what does a citizen owe the city?
Crito begins with a practical proposal: Socrates’ friend wants him to escape from prison. Socrates asks what would be right to do, rather than treating survival or public opinion as sufficient reasons. The discussion includes an imagined address by the laws of Athens, which challenges the justice of his departure.
The text is short enough to reread after the first encounter. Pay attention to who is speaking when the laws are personified and what Socrates has already agreed with Crito. The argument depends on those commitments; it is more specific than a slogan that citizens must always obey.
For a later treatment of conscience and political obligation, read Henry David Thoreau’s writing on resistance to government. Comparing the questions each text asks is more rewarding than assuming in advance that their circumstances or conclusions are the same.
Reading the arguments as literature
These works offer positions to examine, but they also have settings, speakers and changes of pressure. A conversation outside a court and a discussion in prison place their arguments under different conditions. Notice impatience, confidence, interruptions and the moment when a participant wants to leave. The form is part of what you are reading.
Readers who enjoy testing brief claims about human conduct may also turn to La Rochefoucauld’s Maxims. The contrast in form is useful: a maxim compresses an observation into a short statement, while a dialogue lets an objection enter the work as another voice.
When choosing a printed translation of Plato, look for explanatory notes and the standard page-and-letter references known as Stephanus numbers, which help locate passages across editions. Keep the author and translator distinct from the central speaker. There is no collection of books authored by Socrates to complete; there are several ancient ways of bringing his questions before a reader.



